Academy of International Business-Midwest
Manuscript Reviewer Form

(Note:  Your identity will NOT be revealed to the author(s).  Only your feedback comments provided in Box 11 below will be shared with the author(s) for the purpose of helping the author(s) improve the paper.  Thank you for your service and assistance).

Reviewer Name :          Manuscript Number:
                                   First name                                   Last name

Manuscript Title:

Evaluation Criteria Poor Average/Good Excellent
1 2 3 4 5 6 7 8 9 10
1.  Significance/Relevance: The extent to which the manuscript addresses an important issue/problem/phenomenon in International Business management/strategy
2.  Conceptual Rigor: Treatment of relevant literature, logical reasoning, etc.
3.  Methodological Rigor (select one category):
a) For an Empirical manuscript: The extent to which the manuscript presents an appropriate research design, sample, measures, and analysis.
b) For a Theoretical manuscript: The extent to which the manuscript presents an appropriate model, conceptual framework or proposition to facilitate further research.
4.  Clarity of Presentation and Readability: The extent to which the manuscript is well written (grammar, organization, flow)
5.  Insights Offered and Richness of Implications for Practitioners.
6.  Potential Contribution: The extent to which the manuscript contributes to the knowledge of International Business theory and practice
7.  Member Interest: The extent to which the manuscript is likely to be of interest to Midwest AIB/MBAA members, including managers/practitioners
8.  OVERALL EVALUATION
 
9.  Recommendation to Track Chair:
Definitely
Reject		 Probably
Reject		 Accept only
if space allows		 Accept Definitely
Accept

 

(Please respond to Q. 10)
 

Please respond to Question 10 if you rate this manuscript "Definitely Accept"

10. If manuscript is rated "Definitely Accept", is this a Best Paper Candidate?          No           Yes

11.  Feedback to authors (Please provide constructive feedback and suggestions for improvement.  Only information provided in this box will be shared with the author[s]).

Thank you for completing this Review Form.  Please select SUBMIT to electronically submit your evaluation.  Again, thank you for your service to Midwest AIB.